top of page

WHERE THE RESEARCH GOES

Features the annotated bibliographies in relation with the Historical Conversations Project, the Advocacy Project, and Solutions to Advocacy Project for the Writing 39C essay. The annotated bibliographies serve as a summary of what each of the source is about before we actually wrote the essay. It serves as a summary of the main idea of the source, annotated important pieces of information, and as a reference point to look at when trying to connect the sources together.

study.png

SOURCES FOR THE LITERATURE REVIEW OF DOLPHIN COGNITION

-Features a picture of a study and the testing of their ability of numerousity.

Tomanaga, Masaki. “Bottlenose Dolphins' (Tursiops Truncatus) Theory of Mind as Demonstrated by Responses to Their Trainers’ Attentional States.” International Journal of Comparative Psychology, 2010, pp. 310–330.

​

Masaki Tomonaga, Cognition researcher of chimpanzees and dolphins at Kyoto University, discusses the theory of mind exhibited by dolphins in his study “Bottlenose Dolphins' (Tursiops truncatus) Theory of Mind as Demonstrated by Responses to their Trainers’ Attentional States” in the International Journal of Comparative Psychology. Through this study, Tomonaga wanted to test the theory of mind existence in a more controlled environment(aquarium) than different research before. The method he used to do this were with in line with previous social cognitive experiments, which were based off the Baron-Cohen’s system which were used as a standard for chimpanzee cognition and later applied to dolphin cognition. The experiment consisted of different trainers who would perform gestural signs(gestures) and would study the dolphin’s reaction to the gestural signs. While testing the dolphins in another environment than previous dolphin research based off the system, a unique aspect of his experiment included the aspect of testing the role of eye contact when performing these gestural signs.

​

Marino, Lori, and Diana Reiss. “Mirror Self-Recognition in the Bottlenose Dolphin: A Case of Cognitive Convergence.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, May 2001, pp. 5937–5942.

​

Lori Marino and Diana Reiss, Senior professor of Emory university and Cetacean researcher respectively, examines the possibility of mirror self-recognition in dolphins in their study “Mirror self-recognition in the bottlenose dolphin: A case of cognitive convergence,” published by Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. Previously before the research, the ability of mirror self-recognition was recognized in chimpanzees but not fully confirmed for dolphins. Since they still considered the human standard as a basis during the time, it was important to find out whether humans were “the only species to conceive of their own identity.”  Lori Marino and Diana Reiss are both respectable names mentioned throughout the review of dolphin literature and the topic of mirror self-recognition works well with other two topics which relates to cognition in some sort of way.

​

Kilian, Annete, et al. “A Bottlenose Dolphin Discriminates Visual Stimuli Differing in Numerosity.” Learning & Behavior, 2003, pp. 133–142.

​

Annete Kilian and other researchers, dolphin researchers, decided to test dolphins and their capability for numerosity in the study “A bottlenose dolphin discriminates visual stimuli differing in numerosity,” published in the journal Learning & Behavior.  Annete and her colleagues designed the experiment I order to explore the rarely encroached field of the dolphin’s ability to for numerosity(counting). They featured two types of methods, to tests this, one through 3d shapes and one through 2D shapes that featured numbered shapes. This ultimately helps alongside with the cognition topics discussed since it features one of the variety of subjects under the umbrella of cognition.

​

MORE ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES FOR THE SECOND PART OF HCP

cage.png

Neo, Harvey, and J.z. Ngiam. “Contesting Captive Cetaceans: (Il)Legal Spaces and the Nature of Dolphins in Urban Singapore.” Social & Cultural Geography, vol. 15, no. 3, 2014, pp. 235–254., doi:10.1080/14649365.2014.882974.

Harvey Neo and J.Z. Ngiam, professor at National university of Singapore and Yishun Junior College, published “Contesting captive cetaceans: (il)legal spaces and the nature of dolphins in urban Singapore,” in order to address the issues surrounding dolphin captivity at the time. Neo and Ngiam pry into the current problems about dolphin captivity, but questions the morals, spatial, socio-cultural and legal environments surrounding dolphin captivity. It views both viewpoints, those of captivity and anti-captivity, which can be used as to note counter points and be considered when making rebuttals to captivity supporters. This can be used to transition into a new subject, the problems with the Taiji hunt and what it results in.

 

“Facts About Captivity.” Dolphin Project, dolphinproject.com/campaigns/captivity-industry/facts-about-captivity/.

Facts about Captivity, one of the informational pages in Ric O Barry’s Dolphins project website, provides the detriments and the sufferings that the animals go through. It goes through various aspects about dolphin captivity, from physical conditions to the brutal training methods that the businesses implement for them to perform. It defines the problems with captivity for dolphins and how the captivity deteriorates the dolphin’s mental and physical condition. With the first source, this could be a transition from the morals and legal environment that the dolphins are contained in, to the actual problems that the dolphins face in captivity.

 

Isakowitz, Lucas. “The Taiji Dolphin Slaughter Is Back and As Brutal As Ever.” Project Earth, Projectearth.us, 1 Oct. 2017, projectearth.us/the-taiji-dolphin-slaughter-is-back-and-as-brutal-as-ev-1818819394.

Lucas Isakowitz, a writer at project, defines Taiji Hunt and the controversy surrounding the hunt with his article “The Taiji Dolphin Slaughter Is Back and As Brutal As Ever.” It addresses the problems with Taiji hunt as well as the continued opposition against the hunt. It also details the physical problems in eating cetaceans. This too plays a part with the issues of dolphin captivity, since most of the dolphins trapped in the cages are often caught and prepared for business at this location.

Annotated bibliographies

THE SOLUTIONS TO THE AP

dolphin sanctuary.png

“End The Senseless Slaughter In Taiji.” Dolphin Project, dolphinproject.com/take-action/save-japan-dolphins/.

End the Senseless Slaughter in Taiji, one of the informational pages in Ric O Barry’s Dolphins project website, describes many ways of protesting or taking action for the dolphins in Taiji. Dolphins project is a popular activist for cetacean issues and is one of the main organizations that lead the fight for dolphins in Taiji. The site goes through indirect methods such as letters of protest to officials, taking pledges, or signing petitions. It suggests directly contacting authorities in Japan or organizations that have influence/ties to the trade. This source can be used mainly as a grassroots solution to what can be done about the Taiji hunt.

 

Rose, Naomi A. “A Win-Win Solution for Captive Orcas and Marine Theme Parks.” CNN, Cable News Network, 28 Oct. 2013, www.cnn.com/2013/10/24/opinion/blackfish-captive-orcas-solutions/index.html.

CNN, a popular news media source, outlines one of the most direct solutions to dolphin captivity, Dolphin sanctuaries. It first goes through the harsh conditions that cetaceans suffer in the tank. Then it covers the benefits of sanctuaries and how they improve the conditions of the dolphins.  It also covers how this one solution can achieve activist’s goals and Marine theme parks goals. This source can be used as a direct solution, besides grassroots, to solve the problems that plague dolphins in captivity today.

​

“Orca Responsibility and Care Advancement (ORCA) Act (H.R. 1584).” Orca Responsibility and Care Advancement (ORCA) Act, awionline.org/content/orca-responsibility-and-care-advancement-orca-act-h-r-1584.

Animal Welfare institute, a popular animal rights group, covers in article about legislation of HR 1584, an act that concerns the captivity of these animals. It goes through how captivity works and how the legislation was formed and drafted. It notes of the bill’s solution to captivity, by banning it while allowing for the transfer of cetaceans. Although this bill has already been passed, I plan on using this source as a basis on how this could be expanded upon to other countries or by the use of other sources form an argument on how this could be stronger in order for the captivity problem to be solved.

  • twitter
  • generic-social-link

©2018 BY ALLABOUTANIMALS4. PROUDLY CREATED WITH WIX.COM

bottom of page