top of page
The Advocacy Project

The documentary "The superior human" where I started to be intrigued by dolphins.

“The largest animal in the ocean and the largest living land animal were no more than a hundred yards apart, and I was convinced that they were communicating” (Safina 115). As I read “Beyond words,” it taught me much more about the world of animals, but this description of the interaction by Lyall Watson helped lead me into the incredible world of cetaceans.  Cetaceans are a group of large sea animals, including the dolphin, whale and porpoise. Dolphins intrigued me the most, when I learned about their remarkable ability to analyze humans through sonar and be able to detect tumors better than machines in the documentary The Superior Human (16:40-17:00). In addition to their physical capabilities, their general kindness toward humans in scenarios such as protecting surfers from great white sharks draws much attention to the species (Safina 372). We should not, however, only value cetacean abilities that are useful to us; they are as interesting and as complex as us in many ways.

Scientific research concerning the intelligence and behavior of cetaceans started in the 1960s-1970s.  Even though they are structured differently based on anatomy, they possibly hold intelligence on par with other primates and humans, their “cetacean neocortex has a degree of regional parcellation comparable to that of many terrestrial mammals(us)” (Marino 0967). In addition, they form complex social relationships similar to how humans do; Randell Wells discusses of a remarkable situation of a group of female dolphins working together to get more fish, but also to keep each other company, providing evidence of friendship (Zimmer 44). These are obviously very complex animals who live full and meaningful lives, but also hold complex cognitive skills as well.

​

I shall review here three studies which analyze the complexity of cognition in dolphins. I will especially focus on the more recent studies of dolphin cognition while also reviewing previous studies that cover the background information of the studies, as well as include relevant current information. I will also provide reasoning on how cognition has already been proven by the previous studies and how the scientific discussion, is focused on the complexity behind the cognitive potential in the dolphin’s brain. Because cognition is a complex idea, researchers have analyzed it through several perspectives, including the studies reviewed here focused on numerosity, theory of mind, and mirror self-recognition.

Comparison of brains, notice the little physical differences between the two.

Lori Marino and Diana Reiss,respectively, who released the first study proving Dolphin self-recognition.

Mirror Self Recognition

The mirror test was originally created by Gordon Gallup as a test of Mirror self-recognition,the ability of a species to identify themselves in a mirror as an image of itself. However, no one had ever adequately tested Mirror Self-recognition with dolphins properly. This ended when Diana Reiss and Lori Marino, dolphin cognition researchers, released their study “Mirror self-recognition in the bottlenose dolphin: A case of cognitive convergence” in 2003. Unlike their previous peers in the field, Reiss and Marino successfully set up proper conditions to test for the environment. The methodology consisted of observing dolphins who were exposed to a mirror when they were being “marked, sham-marked(water ink), or not marked(unmarked).” (Reiss 5937-5942) The tank that held the subject often featured two reflective surfaces, one an actual mirror while the other was an extremely reflective surface. Procedures were developed to create situations where one reflective surface was present, or both were present. Behaviors were coded as Self-directed (mark-directed, sham-directed, or exploratory), Nondirected, Ambiguous, or Social. Mark- and sham-directed, to determine self-recognition.

The results from the experiment helped clear many doubts but also brought more questions to the field of dolphin cognition. The first dolphin when marked often spent more time in mark- or sham-directed behaviors at the best available reflective surface when marked. When the dolphins had no mark, they did not display any social behavior toward the mirror and did not interact with it. Even when marked, they displayed different social behaviors than usual indicating their ability to recognize themselves in the mirror. The second subject showed similar behaviors to the first and showed the same social behaviors as the first in the same contexts. With all this evidence, this study became the first convincing argument that a nonprimate, like a dolphin, possessed the ability to perform Mirror Self Recognition. This study encouraged researchers to test more cognitively complex skills since it was proven that the type of brain (Primate brain versus dolphin brain) can show similar skills although different. This helped lead other studies such as theory of mind and numerosity.

Theory of mind

Theory of Mind was first developed by David Premack and Guy Woodruff and is defined as the “ability to perceive the unique perspective of others and its influence on their behavior” (Learning theories). Most of these experiments testing theory of mind followed Baron-Cohen’s (1995) mindreading system: understanding intentions and understanding direction of gaze. Masaki Tomonaga, a primatology professor at Kyoto University, released the 2010 study “Bottlenose Dolphins' (Tursiops truncatus) Theory of Mind as Demonstrated by Responses to their Trainers’ Attentional States” to test whether dolphins needed both conditions of Baron-Cohen’s mindreading system to successfully exhibit theory of mind through the recognition of gestural signs. It also tested the dolphin’s capabilities to engage in mental rotation or the ability to recognize an gestural sign(hand signs) when the object has been rotated. Mental rotation was tested by changing the dolphin’s perspective angle away from the trainer through a head turn, body turn, or head and body turn (0, 45, 90, 135, 180 degrees). Each successful or non-successful reaction to gesture was recorded. When the trainers stood directly in front of them with or without the bucket, the dolphins were recorded to have a successful (>90%) reaction rate when given the signal. However, as the trainers rotated clockwise in their position, each dolphin’s ability to recognize and perform signs got rapidly worse than at 0 degrees.

The study proved that eye contact does not matter, and that dolphins simply need intention, or signs in this case, to fully comprehend what the trainers want them to do. The study established that mental rotation does make a difference for dolphins. When the degree of rotation for body, head, or body and head was not 0 each dolphin showed much worse results than the initial 0-degree success as shown in the figure below, each dolphin saw drastic drops in accuracy. This proves to be important since it proves that dolphins do not necessarily surpass other species in cognition, but also opens questions on what level of cognition dolphins possess in comparison with us, and which cognitive skills they can practice in similarity to us.

 

​

A trainer controlling two dolphins at the Port of Nagoya Public Aquarium. He used his
right hand to show the sign for “hold” to the dolphin on the left in the picture while making eye
contact with the dolphin on the right.

Displays the results of the rotation tests in response to gestural signs.

Schematic overview of a test situation with heterogeneous stimuli
in Experiment 1.

Schematic overview of a test situation in Experiment 2 with stimuli
with an overall equal surface area for the elements.

Numerosity

Speaking of similar skills, one of the oldest animal cognition studies was based on the concept of numerosity, or the ability for an animal to differentiate or “comprehend quantity by way of visual, audile, or other sensorial systems” (Psychology dictionary). Annete Kilian, a bottlenose dolphin cognition researcher at Ruhr University Bochum, published the study “A bottlenose dolphin discriminates visual stimuli differing in numerosity” (2003) to solve the numerosity question for dolphins. The methodology featured a young dolphin in captivity who was tested through the means of objects hanging down from the floating hoops already in the water. Different sorts of objects were hung from these hoops and changed frequently to test whether homogenous compositions and heterogeneous compositions of the test affected the reaction of the dolphin. Spatial compositions were also changed to ensure that the dolphin was not responding to the experiment based on the familiar pattern, but instead focusing on the numerosity of the objects on the floating hoops. Overall, the dolphin was able to correctly identify the objects with the most stimuli. Although it had trouble with spatial compositions, after extensive training, the dolphin became better at detecting numerosity under spatial conditions. The dolphin showed comparable results with two dimensional stimuli as well. Therefore, through the publication of this study, Kilian and her coworkers successfully showed that dolphins indeed have the innate capability of learning/exercising numerosity. It also demonstrates the power of visuals in cognition. Although not discussed earlier, numerosity and gestural signs do have a common trait, the reliance on visuals to perform.

Conclusion

I reviewed various form of dolphin cognition in this literature review. While not proving simple cognition, I have provided convincing evidence of similar complex cognitive skills between humans and dolphins. Through the numerosity study, I have shown that dolphins can discriminate numbers between two similar numbered stimuli. I discussed mirror self-recognition, and dolphin’s potential to process the skill faster than us and dwelled on the understanding they possess toward gestural signs. They are extremely intelligent animals with the same potential as us, just in a different body. With this knowledge in hand, we should treat dolphins and perhaps all animals more differently. There are many more that are undiscovered intelligent creatures but yet are treated poorly. The plentiful research now on dolphins however, should be utilized. These creatures know what they are doing. Yet we put them in captivity, for the benefit of the rich and the delight of the people. They should not be stagnating in the tank. While putting their cognitive potential to a minimum we make them perform in conditions such as sunburn, chlorination eye burning, and stress.  We need to let them lead their own enriching lives. Not as an enricher of ours.

The Problem

Some people do not understand what is the wrong behind the aquatic animal entertainment business. They point to the fair treatment of land animals in zoos, but the reality of the aquarium business is entirely different. Zoos appropriately prepare an environment where animals can thrive, Lions have appropriate surroundings and monkeys have trees to interact with.They are treated and well fed. For cetaceans it is different. They need to have the appropriate space in order to explore and move. The World Animal Protection, an international non-profit animal welfare organization, says that dolphins may “swim up to 40 or 50 miles in a day” and “have access to less than 1/10,000 of 1% (0.000001%) of the space available to them in their natural environment,” demonstrating the stark contrasts with land animals who do not need to move as often. (World Animal Protection) This seems like an overstatement of the conditions that the animals go through. Yet it is the truth and is wrong on various levels. Jeremy Bentham, a famous British philosopher, states “The question is not whether they(animals) reason or whether they talk, but whether they(animal) suffer” (Ryder 2:56-3:10).  In any case or scenario, we normally would not harm other humans, so what makes it ok to hurt animals? In “Singer on Animal Rights and Vegetarianism,” it features Peter Singer and Richard Dawkins, evolutionary biologist and philosopher respectively, as they discuss pain in animals and whether it is morally correct. One of the most convincing arguments I discovered was when they delved into slavery. They discussed how we are “a socially conforming species” and how the issue of animal treatment is similar to slavery in the 1800s, it should not be accepted but is accepted as the “social norm” (9:00-9:30). Although they focused on farm animals that are raised to be slaughtered, dolphins experience similar conditions. In particular, I will focus on the wrongs of the animal business industry, the cruel continuous suffering of the dolphins in captivity from their initial capture to the poor conditions they experience inside the tank, while also honing on why we should not continue to support such businesses.

Dolphins and cetaceans in captivity are often seen to be fun and playful creatures in the aquarium. However, behind this initial happiness we see from the dolphins at businesses like SeaWorld, the suffering of the dolphins continues. Ric O’ Barry’s Dolphin project highlights many of the struggles that dolphins experience inside captivity. One of the struggles is lack of mental stimulation, they live in an isolated tank (Dolphin Project). Dolphins do the same routine everyday, perform, rest, and eat. Cycle that over multiples of years and their mind degenerates.  In addition to the mental deterioration, forced habits such as tubing (tubes pushed down into the mouth into the stomach) and habit of starving the dolphins for them to practice and perform is another widespread practice within the industry (Dolphin Project). They are also impacted physically as well. They often have problems with tanks being over chlorinated, which burn the dolphin’s eyes, while the tank exposure to sun creates blisters and sunburns (Dolphin Project). The beak riding, kisses, or the photo ops that the children and adults do to interact with the animal, harms the dolphins physically as the interaction leaves their beaks extremely raw (Dolphin Project). In the words of Bentham, these animals do indeed suffer, so how is it morally right to keep them in these tanks under poor conditions and let the businesses profit off suffering.  These all sound like terrible conditions for these animals. Yet, how is this treated as normal?

Some people highlight it’s the way of nature, a dog eats dog world, so they approve of the treatment of animals such as the dolphins in aquariums because we are dominant therefore we can and should do whatever we want, nature allowed us too. Yet this should not be the correct way of thinking about the sufferings of animals. Our dominance in the animal kingdom is irrelevant to the wrongs of showcasing the animals. This only applies to the prey or animals we eat, but when we start showcasing animals and willingly put them in terrible conditions, then the argument of our dominance over animals is questionable, because we do not use them as food nor do we see them as prey, they just serve for our own entertainment. Captivity is wrong on so many levels, but the way some of these cetaceans are captured is even worse.

Every year from September to March, a brutal massacre and capturing of dolphins and cetaceans occurs on the shores of one Japanese town. In an article by Project Earth, Lucas Isakowitz explains how the Taiji hunt is the “among the world’s largest dolphin hunts, both in terms of raw number of dolphins killed and the number of species targeted.”(Project Earth) Even in recent years, as the public became more aware through movies such as “The Cove,” Taiji continues to hunt and are allowed to capture up to nearly two thousand dolphins for capture and kill for the 2017/2018 season (Cetabase). Similar to what Dawkins and Singer discussed, social norm plays a part when the Japanese preserve their tradition. This does not mean that this act is any more wrong than it is. If anything, the main motive seems to lie behind greed, as the dolphins captured can be worth $40000-$80000 (Project Earth). The process before the captivity, sounds bad yet it’s just all controlled by business.

Harvey Neo and J.Z. Ngiam, professor at National university of Singapore and Yishun Junior College respectively, published “Contesting captive cetaceans: (il)legal spaces and the nature of dolphins in urban Singapore,” in order to address the issues surrounding dolphin captivity at the time. Primarily, through the review of other studies, Neo and Ngiam discuss how businesses set their own standards of treatment for the dolphins. Through research they find “Hybrid places such as zoos and marine parks are governed by local laws” and “zoos self regulate by setting industry standards,” (Ngiam and Neo 246-247) indicating that businesses are all in control, and that they have the possibility to maximize profit and do as little as possible to provide for the dolphins. In defense of Animals, an animal rights organization, highlights on the page “10 Worst Tanks for Dolphins and Whales,” how Seaworld “withdrew its previously submitted proposal to expand the size of its San Diego orca tanks,” indicating how these companies may release public relations announcements that says one thing, but may never follow it through, showing that they are fully in control of making the decisions (In Defense of Animals). In another Ngiam and Neo find that captivity is usually reserved for animals that are endangered yet bottlenose dolphins are not thought to be endangered (Ngiam and Neo 246). We allow animals to be caught and captured and displayed in aquariums and zoos across the world, not thinking about whether it is natural or not. The system of exploitation and suffering all starts with business, from Taiji to captivity, and it is the one word that keeps this system all together.

While this may be an overreaction, dolphins severly lack the space to swim what they formally swim in the wild, often swimming in circles in the tanks.

Peter Singer and Richard Dawkins video that engages in the philosophical discussion about animal rights.

Dolphin sunburned cause by overexposure of the sun due to the shallow waters of the tank.

Picture demonstrates Taiji hunt and how they catch the dolphins.

Conditions that result from the supervision of business and lack of regulation.

Informational video about military noise and how it affects cetaceans.

Empty the tanks is a protest that has been started by activists and regularly tweeted about in the cetacean activism community.

Blackfish is one of the main documentaries that propelled the movement against businesses like Seaworld for the way they treat their aquatic animals.

Promotional Ad about Florida's Orca Protection Act.

How sanctuaries would possibly be look like in the future.

The Solution

I now reviewed one of the most important problems facing dolphins today, the captivity of cetaceans. While some people may point to military noise, fishermen bycatching, or Taiji hunt as factors that affect a huge number of dolphins, dolphin captivity has its roots in entertainment business. This makes it overall easier to protest against and change in comparison with dealing with the military politics to solve military noise, the fisherman lobby and the vast amount of consumers it has, or the international politics to persuade the people in charge of Taiji hunt to stop. There are plenty of other avenues of entertainment that does not hurt cetaceans/animals and the prices of the aquatic businesses can easily deter people from visiting aquariums that features these cetaceans.  However, what are these solutions that can help solve the dolphin captivity problem? Like many of the activist’s solutions today, it all starts with the grassroots.

    Grassroots is defined as a movement that utilizes people in the bottom of an organization in order to advocate for a problem or solution. Social Media is often the most popular for grassroots movements. While other people use it to share their life with friends and family, activists see it as a way to appeal to people. Twitter especially has become popular out of most, due to its Trending section which can easily gather people around one issue very easily and very fast.  For example, in the cetacean activist community #Dontbuyaticket and #Emptythetanks became popular with these organizations on Twitter when Seaworld CEO Joel Manby left his position after a year of poor sales due to the movie “Blackfish” and activist protests (Selk). The potential of social media is great especially for activism organizations since they can use publicity from these popular moments to educate and inform the public about the problems and attempt to gather people on their opinion in order to ramp up support. If one wanted to advocate for the ending of Taiji hunts let’s say, grassroots is one of the solutions. For example on their website for “Orcas and Dolphins Do Not Belong in Captivity!” Dolphin project highlights of ways, activists or people interested in protesting the subject can do in order to stop dolphin captivity (Dolphin Project). The site goes through indirect methods such as letters of spreading the word through social media, taking pledges, or signing petitions all which could influence the authorities in charge of the business to make a change about captivity (Dolphin Project). However, one person can only do so much. Although, grassroots have made many movements in history very successful, the animal rights activist movement is not as big or huge as in the past. Divide that by species, and the activists listed dwindles. Therefore, grassroots is not as effective, but lobbying for laws can be.

    However, in comparison to grassroots, while laws are more complex, they are overall much more impactful and legally binding. While companies and business do not necessarily follow the suggestions from people when the public relations controversies surrounding their treatment of animals appear, they cannot disobey the law. Another benefit of the law is that while there are few successes, the successes achieved can be used as a framework for laws for other states. The Orca Protection Act that passed in California was signed into law by Governor Brown in 2016 and “bans holding orcas in captivity for performance or entertainment purposes in California, and ends captive breeding programs and the import/export of orcas and their genetic material into/out of the state” (Animal Welfare Institute). This proved to be one of the first laws of it’s kind and has encouraged other states to introduce their own bills such as Florida recently in January 2018 or the federal Orca and Responsibility and Care Act(ORCA) in 2017 (Whale Dolphin Conservation). While this is applied to orcas, this could expand to other species such as Dolphins quite easily. Yet, lobbying for laws for animal rights can be difficult and an arduous process. Often times the best solution to a problem is through cooperation from both sides, and that’s what sanctuaries plan to do.

    While not a new idea, the idea of sanctuaries has been supported by cetacean activist groups, such as Dolphin Project, for quite a while. In a CNN article “A win-win solution for captive orcas and marine theme parks,” by Naomi Rose, she highlights the use of a sanctuary to satisfy the wants of the activists and the needs of the business (Rose). While activists want the animals to be released, it is often known that the animals that are born in the business often cannot adjust well enough when released to the ocean and often die. Yet, the activists want the cetaceans to have enough room to be fully active and in conditions like the wild instead of being under constant watch by visitors. The sanctuary serves both purposes, as it “offer the animals respite from performing and the constant exposure to a parade of strangers” and would serve as “cold water natural habitat” for the cetaceans (Rose). Also the process of making and building a sanctuary is eased by learning from already established and successful wildlife sanctuaries as well as from formed partnerships such as Merlin Entertainment and Whale and Dolphin Conservation which aims to build cetacean retiring sanctuaries for their performing animals (Mountain). Current activist organizations, such as Dolphin Project has participated in the successful rehabilitation of dolphins from tank to wild as reviewed in their page “Readapting captive dolphins” (Dolphin Project).  Marine theme parks too could benefit through sometimes opening up the sanctuary for others to view, similar to what they operate now, but under closer supervision and with the animals in their natural state (Rose). Overall, this would be one of the best solutions to solve dolphin captivity. It solves many of the physical detriments that dolphins experience regularly in the tank, and puts the dolphins back in its own natural environment with plenty of space to swim. Sanctuaries can still be profitable for businesses to work in, while the cetaceans experience their natural habitat.

Dolphin project's logo.

Dolphin looking at oneself in mirror.

The final product that the previous pages helped build up to, the entire essay featuring the HCP, AP and Solutions to the AP.

  • twitter
  • generic-social-link

©2018 BY ALLABOUTANIMALS4. PROUDLY CREATED WITH WIX.COM

bottom of page