top of page

The Superior Human? NOT.

Feb 11, 2018
3 min read

I found the film "The Superior Human" to be extremely persuasive in its argument against the supposed superiority humans have over all animals. In the end, I was firmly impressed by the video and the systematic pick apart of the argument human supremacists have designed. Human supremacists are people who champion humans as the "final form" or the most superior species above all the species. The first thirty minutes that featured the various details of the human supremacist hooked me in with the argument the most. Simply because every reason seemed to have some flaw or counterexample that could be cited. An excellent argument they made was the language reason. The video went in depth of how we were special based on our communication with language, but in reality language is not unique to us only. Kanzi, a primate, was even able to understand our own language and communicate with others. Besides the systematic destruction of the human supremacist argument I learned about several new characteristics of some animals. I was particularly impressed by the helpful abilities some animals have to us. For example, dolphins could detect humors, cats can detect death, while dogs can detect cancers and strokes. All remarkable capabilities but no recognition from humans often times. The prairie dog language segment was particularly impressive. It emulates much of the human language through the prairie dog's usage of adjectives and verbs and weirdly posses the ability to identify new things and when in isolated scenarios, all the prairie dogs name the item the same name. Safina, similar to the movie picks apart the argument that Humans are superior. His argument that humans should judge animals based on their own capabilities and not comparing them to ours, was an effective argument that opposed the idea of human supremacy, but instead posed that every species was special in their own way. The article also went through speciesism , very similar to racism, the idea that some species are superior to other species. One of the most baffling information I learned through this video, would probably be the discussion of Descartes and his idea of the mystical mind, and how humans had it, and animals did not. Therefore, animals were machines who can act like they felt pain, but in reality did not feel pain at all. It just did not make sense to me, that such a prestigious philosopher could state such things. Even more baffling, was that people still follow this ideal to this day, and practice this on animals. The way of the Dodo, was the last insight I derived from the video. Interestingly, it posed our survival as a species as questionable and that we would likely die out in 1.8-3.8 million years or even go extinct faster than the dodo's existence, which is often mocked as a stupid bird. It made me question our human superiority, and how various species besides us outlived longer than us. Even if they do not have the same capabilities or deemed not as great, they are still alive. If we die out anytime, it would be hard to pin as the best species, when other species have outlived far worst situations. Overall, the video built on the knowledge we have learned from Safina, and continues to build on our knowledge of what we know about animals so far.


 
 
 

Comments


  • twitter
  • generic-social-link

©2018 BY ALLABOUTANIMALS4. PROUDLY CREATED WITH WIX.COM

bottom of page