My AP reflection
The AP process, The Beginning
Initially at the start, I more or less understood the problems that faced my species through the consistent use of daily twitter, as well as just researching my species and topic(dolphin cognition) in general. For twitter, this mainly came from finding organizations suggested by the articles we have read, then using the suggested follows sidebar on the right side of twitter, to see what I could find. I mostly found myself exploring researchers and organizations, but ultimately decided to focus on organizations since these tended to be more specific for my AP later on. Since the organizations, often followed each other and as I narrowed down for my animal topic from week 1 to the week of the HCP, I managed to find important organizations about dolphins and cetaceans in general. I felt curious with these first weeks, since I was just exploring the class and had no clue about what to do so i mainly drifted page to page, looking for credible researchers and organizations which could help me in the future. After, finishing the HCP and putting more emphasis on the Advocacy project, I put more efforts into finding more about ideas about problems so I specifically scoured my following page to find any relevant profiles related to dolphins and from their expanded my keywords/problems for my Advocacy project. Social media, also helped me introduce to articles which discussed the impacts of the problems or defined the problems for me, so it made it easier to understand. For my scholarly journal, I searched Ebscohost's Academic Search complete with keywords such as "Taiji," "military noise," and others until I narrowed it down to "Captivity," where I found an excellent journal entry about the morality and general consensus on dolphin captivity.

Figure 1 Some organizations/profiles that I found to be helpful in my search for sources in the Advocacy projects.
The AP process, The Troubles
While, it does sound like that I had it all figured it out during the beginning, I had some struggles when actually putting the ideas on paper. Initially I thought about designing a 3 problem essay where it discussed three different problems and later discuss solutions in the next part. However, the links and research I found on topics such as Military noise just did not seem to be appropriate for the essay(since I wanted to focus purely on dolphins), so while doing the annotated bibliographies for the sources, I had to change course and decided to put more emphasis on captivity, where I could more or less link Taiji, the wrongs of captivity, and the morality of captivity together. So I decided to change my formatting of the problem instead to focus on Captivity alone as a one problem format for my Advocacy project, instead of the three problem one which I had problems with connecting. This improved my ability to be flexible but also creative in my thinking of drafting the Advocacy project. I became more flexible by finding more ideas that could work with each other, as well as creative since I had to find a way to link the sources all together to make a strong cohesive Advocacy project.

Figure 2 A thread I posted for the SMC, where I found the problem I could discuss, later removed from my main sources.
The AP process, Revising and Editing
When I finished my draft for the Advocacy project, I was rather unhappy with some specific parts of the draft. While trying not to stray from the recommended editing that I should do, I focused on edits that I felt that were completely necessary in order for the essay to flow better and make more sense. Since my essay was too long for the requirements and specifications, catching me a bit off guard, I decided to put heightened focus on cutting down the pages on my paper while attempting to retain the quality of it. I took out unnecessary multi-modal elements and reduced it to one, removing any that felt too unnecessary and kept the one that was simple and easy to understand. I also got rid of unnecessary sentences which, although informational, were not vital to the essay. I also brushed up on the last paragraph of the HCP , in order to make it more relevant to the AP, by introducing a new tone that contrasted the rest of the HCP beforehand, and in order to inform the reader I aimed for in the next few pages. This part specifically, improved my flexibility to react to unexpected situations, I had troubles with trying to make the new requirements work with the current state of the essay, but in the end I managed to get it with a fair amount of pages and quality.
Peer review
My peer review's partner essay was actually very similar to mine in a way, since he discussed orcas, another part of the cetacean classification. My first impression of it was that while I understood the intentions of the author most of the time in the essay, it just seemed to be too lacking of information or specifics to be a strong convincing problem and solutions essay. I mainly gave the author advice about how to make his essay better, through improvement of flow, change in tone, and inclusion and exclusion of some information so it was not excessive as some points or lacking at other points of the essay. Overall, I want to have more introduction to the topics similar to how he did it, where in the first few paragraphs he goes into depth about the problems and engages in a conversation about the problem, which i want to incorporate in some paragraphs of mine as well. The best advice, I gave was probably the combination of the organization solution(E.g. Dolphin project) and individual solution(which I assume is grassroots). I thought these two were way too similar and could be merged as the grassroots solution while incorporating the discussion of social media.
Almost final draft, how to improve
For my final revision, I think that I will hone in own errors in logic that I may have made throughout the essay, while focusing on the structure of the paragraphs. These are very small fixes however, but I feel like if anything I will spend most of my time on the solutions draft and reworking some of my opposing voices. These two are the main focus since this is simply too fresh to be good, and can be improved more easily in comparison with the HCP and AP, which have been read and reviewed multiple times. I will also get to reading all the peer reviews on canvas one more time and look for the ones that can work well with my essay that I have in mind.






Comments