top of page

Peer Review blog

Mar 5, 2018
3 min read

To start on the peer review of the first draft I started with a quick skimming of the whole essay. The paper I first graded was about dog cognition. I thought while the essay kept focus in line with the Advocacy project and the historical conversations there were various instances where the author could have been more credible/professional. The credibility especially was a concern for me. The title had special characters which I commented seemed inappropriate, while the introduction to the topic could have been better with more relevant information to. One of the best advice I gave was with the concerns over the HCP body paragraphs, where I recommended them to include more background information or introductions to each featured study paragraph, so the subject would be easier to digest for the reader. I also felt the essay was lacking in longevity which I told the author to include more sources and more in-depth information in order to fill the space with relevant information.

My second paper that I peer reviewed seemed to be much better at explaining, but still had problems. It focused on Bird cognition and the problems we create that trouble birds. One of the immediate things I notice in the author’s essay was the introduction. While fantastically written and relevant, the introduction to the HCP seemed to be too philosophical and did not seem appropriate in the discussion of introducing bird cognition. The main thing I noticed that with this current draft, it seems awkward since the tone shift with philosophy to the introduction of the HCP felt inappropriate overall since the author would be philosophical than scholarly in another. Therefore, I felt this was my best recommendation since with a change of introductions and replacing the HCP introduction with another introduction and putting the HCP introduction to the AP introduction, readers would not be so confused about the topic of the draft so early on. I also highlighted, how more sources should be added, background information should be provided, and in-depth information would make the essay much more clearer and longer to fit the page requirements.

I feel that peer review is a helpful informative tool that can highly benefit both the receiver and the person conducting the review. The receiver gets highly useful information that can help the them create a better essay. The conductor thinks about the review and improves it, which can benefit himself/herself since the critical thinking involved in the process helps immensely for their own essay, to look out of the mistakes the other person makes. From my experience, however it has done little, but those trivial things that other people found helped shape a better essay overall. From finding things to cut to improvement in ethos after a suggestion, peer review ultimately was a very helpful resource for me. I think the study “To give is better than to receive” did not apply to me in this scenario. Although, the information that I found were great, what I did during the peer review process did not help me much. The receiving part was what I found the most to help rather than the giving. I feel like I did practice my close reading skills, since I had to closely read the text in order to give out constructive advice and comments.


 
 
 

Comments


  • twitter
  • generic-social-link

©2018 BY ALLABOUTANIMALS4. PROUDLY CREATED WITH WIX.COM

bottom of page